The challenge of cultural relativism essay

The Challenge of Cultural Relativism Essay

Hence, we are stuck at the same problem; objectivity or no objectivity. There can be none and cultural relativism brings doubt to the idea of moral progress Rachels, J. The difference is in our belief systems, not in our values.

Challenge of Cultural Relativism

Because Cultural Relativism says that these judgments make no sense, the argument goes, it cannot be right. Consider again the example of the Greeks and Callatians.

It is easy to see that, in fact, all cultural groups must protect their infants: Here is an outline: As a beginning, we may distinguish the following claims, all of which have been made by cultural relativists: We could also adopt the opposing thought that if we agree that a culture has made moral progress, then cultural relativism must be false Cutler, D.

It follows that in any complex society there must be a presumption in favor of truthfulness. Cultural Relativism would preclude us from saying that either of these practices was wrong.

All in all, the Eskimo practice was a volatile scheme that bore little resemblance to what we call marriage. There are many cases where this tolerance is a much needed breath of fresh view points, but cultural relativism also dictates that we must be tolerant of all cultural practices, not just the ones we like.

It is mere arrogance for us to try to judge the conduct of other peoples. Moreover, the writer pointed out that even experience can tell us that Cultural Relativism is not quite the case; he based this particular argument on the tinges of moral objectivity that we see amidst the cultural differences in values.

So I have no reason to pay attention to your answer; in fact, there was no point in my asking you in the first place.

Moreover, the Eskimos are a nomadic people—unable to farm, they must move about in search of food. Therefore, it is a mistake to overestimate the amount of difference between cultures.

It is merely a matter of opinion, which varies from culture to culture. Could a society exist in which there was no prohibition on murder. This line of thought has probably persuaded more people to be skeptical about ethics than any other single thing.

The premise concerns what people believe. This essay will explore the rules and theories of cultural relativism, what we can learn from cultural relativism as well as the counter argument of where cultural relativism fails us.

However, the tolerance that they teach different societies is of value. The society's values are only one of them. The Challenge of Cultural Relativism. The concept of Cultural Relativism holds that there exist no universal standards of cultural and ethical values in the world against which all other ethical and cultural values and traditions could be judged - The Challenge of Cultural Relativism introduction.

Challenge of Cultural Relativism

All cultural and ethical beliefs and traditions are, therefore, of equal value and have to be evaluated and studied from.

Cultural Relativism begins with the valuable insight that many of our practices are like this; they are only cultural products.

Then it goes wrong by inferring that, because some practices are like this, all must be.

The Challenge of Cultural Relativism - Essay Example

Cultural Relativism Essay Is cultural relativism good for our society? Cultural relativism is a belief where there are no absolute moral views or beliefs can be apply to all cultures, which makes “right” and “wrong” different in every society; what is considered “right” in one society may be considered “wrong” in another.

Section I: Argument Summary: (at least one paragraph on each of these major headings) What is the main argument for cultural relativism? Remember, this.

In order to progress, we must be allowed to judge since there is no such thing as being perfect. Though cultural relativism is needed in society to remind us to keep an open mind.

Rachels on Cultural Relativism

James Rachels mentions in his essay, "The Challenge of Cultural Relativism" that many values in. What is Culture Relativism: Views by James Rachels Essay; What is Culture Relativism: Views by James Rachels Essay Cultural Relativism Essay.

The Challenge of Cultural Relativism

and James Rachels The Challenge of Cultural Relativism to illustrate why moral relativism should be rejected, and deontology should be accepted.

The challenge of cultural relativism essay
Rated 4/5 based on 16 review
The Challenge of Cultural Relativism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - words